Posted by
IndyBlogger on Friday, December 19, 2008 9:34:39 AM
President Bush is right now giving a speech about the bailout for auto makers. He is wrong. What he has been told is wrong. What you are being told is wrong.
Bush said the people understand what the automakers are going thru and want them to succeed. If that were true, the congress and senate should have passed the bill. So no thank you, Mr. President. So Bush has walked away from his party again.
Bush not working with his party is old news, but here are the reason you really want to continue reading. What they aren't telling you.
First GM sells cars at a loss in normal conditions. The make money on the parts and service. So selling less cars is actually positive for cash flow in bad times. In addition in bad times, the need for parts and services usually rises. In which case they should make more money. In recent reports this is in fact true right now. People are buying less cars and getting more parts and service.
So what's the problem?
If you ask them its the union, but labor only made up 10% of the cost. But the government asked for lower union wages. I'm not a true blue union supporter but this doesn't make sense. At its worst it a way for GM to force a negotation on the Union with President in office not smart enough to know what's going on. At its best its just dumb.
Congress and the masses have been saying its executive pay, or they don't make green cars. If changing executive pay would solve the problem, the board of directors could fix that instantly, and they would, because they would never give up their investment, just to have one less out of work CEO. So that's not it. What about the green cars? GM makes 'green' cars, but there best sales have been in gas hogs! If the green cars were running off the lot, they would make more. They are motivated by money. If that made money, they would do more of it. That is the way it should be. Here the thing with these green cars. They may be cute for the city and short trips, but they don't work in mid-west. They don't want them. Clearly the people in the city don't want them either, because they aren't buying them.
Last, they say they just need a loan. Really, that's it. I don't think so, because banks love to loan money to companies that doing well and just need a loan. The Government just made some money available pretty cheap to loan. You might have heard about that lately. They won't loan the money because its to high a risk, because they don't believe the story, that they will make it. Its not just the 'story' its the plan. Here is the difference, GM thought they could trick the government into believing the plan because they just aren't qualified to do that analysis. This is all the banks do every day, but the government isn't really capable and yet they look to make these decisions. The fact that the Senate didn't pass this is a credit to them. And it wasn't the Republicans that blocked it. If all the Dems voted for it, they could have got it done. This lost by close to a 20 point margin.
It could be they just don't want to buy a GM car. Has anyone considered that. That the quality of GM car, which Hannity always defends, still has a bad brand. I don't want to buy any GM car. I might buy a GM truck, but that's far from green. The problem with GM and Chrysler for that matter, is GM and Chrysler. Yes the economy is bad, and that changes things quickly. But the same thing happened to Ford, Toyato, and Honda. Ford got their loan when they didn't NEED the money. A first time business owner learns that lesson pretty quickly, or they aren't around. GM had an entire devision that was in lending, and they couldn't figure this out? GM has been poorly managed. That's it, end of story. Their brand has been poorly managed. Final. They should be doing ok right now, selling fewer cars at a loss and increased parts and service sales. They should already have a loan like Ford. They should make cars that people want to buy and they should restructure their costs so they can be profitable. A government loan is not going to solve those problems any better than bankruptcy court. All we are teaching the American people, is that if you are going to fail, fail big and the government will bail you out.